SoFi

As anyone who has ever watched their bank account balance decline after paying bills knows, owing money is no fun. But debt often serves an important function in people’s lives, putting things that can cost tens of thousands of dollars or more — like a college degree or a starter home — within reach.

Such cases aren’t quite the same as racking up a high credit card balance on restaurant meals and shopping trips, underscoring that when it comes to owing money, there can be good debt and bad debt.

What Is Debt Exactly?

It’s a simple four-letter word, yet debt is often not as straightforward as it may appear. Carrying a credit card balance? That’s debt. Have a student loan or car lease? Also debt.

When individuals owe money, they generally have to pay back more than the amount they borrowed. Most debt is subject to interest, the borrowing cost that is applied based on a percentage of money owed.

Interest accrues over time, so the longer consumers take to pay off debt, the more it may cost them.

Across people and households, debts add up. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, by the end of 2022, total household debt climbed to $16.90 trillion.

Housing debt — specifically mortgages and mortgage refinancing — accounted for the majority of money owed, more than $12 trillion. Non-housing debt, such as credit card balances and school and car loans, accounted for the rest.

For individuals, average debt amounted to $101,915 in the fall of 2022, according to the credit reporting company Experian. While student loan debt was down slightly, shrinking by 1.2% from the year before — many other debts, including amounts owed on credit cards, personal loans, car loans, home equity lines of credit (HELOCs), and mortgages, all increased from the year before, according to Experian.

Recommended: Free Credit Score Monitoring

Good Debt vs Bad Debt

When you have debt, not only do you have to repay the money borrowed, but you also usually incur ongoing costs — specifically interest — which increase the amount you have to pay back.

While incurring more debt probably isn’t the most attractive proposition, there are occasions when taking on debt can be necessary or even beneficial in the long term. This is where good debt vs. bad debt comes in.

Though the idea of good vs. bad debt might seem complicated (and is often subject to some misconceptions), as a rule of thumb, the difference between good debt and bad debt usually has to do with the long-term results of borrowing.

Good debt is seen as money owed on expenditures that can build an individual’s finances over time, such as taking out student loans in order to increase one’s earning potential, or a mortgage on a house that is expected to appreciate in value.

Bad debt is money owed for expenses that pose no long-term value to a person’s financial standing, or that may even decrease in value by the time the loan is paid off. This can include credit card debt and car loans.

While owing money may not feel great, debt can serve some helpful functions. For starters, your credit score is used by lenders to determine eligibility and risk level when it comes to borrowing money.

Your credit score is based on your history of taking on and paying off debt, and helps to inform a lender about how risky a loan may be to issue. Your credit score can play an important role in determining not only whether a credit card or loan application will be approved but also how much interest you will be charged.

With no credit history at all, it may be harder for a lender to assess a loan application. Meanwhile, a solid track record of paying off good debt on time can help inspire confidence.

While there are no guarantees, good debt can also mean short-term pain for long-term gain. That’s because if paid back responsibly, good debt can be an investment in one’s future financial well-being, with the results ultimately outweighing the cost of borrowing.

Conversely, with bad debt, the costs of borrowing add up and may surpass the value of a loan.

Recommended: What is The Difference Between Transunion and Equifax?

What Is Considered Good Debt?

Mortgages

Like other lending products, mortgages are subject to annual interest on the principal amount owed.

In the United States, the average rate of a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage was averaging 6.28% nationally in April 2023, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. That’s up from 2022, when the average rate for a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage was 4.72%.

Meanwhile, data from the Federal Housing Finance Agency showed that home prices grew 8.4% from the end of 2021 to the fourth quarter of 2022.

This illustrates how the potential appreciation of a home might outweigh the cost of financing. But it’s best to not assume that taking on a mortgage to buy a house will increase wealth. Things like neighborhood decline, periods of financial uncertainty, and the individual condition of a home could reduce the value of a given property.

Personal loans or home equity loans used to improve the condition of a home may also increase its value, and in such instances may also be considered “good” debt.

Recommended: Should I Sell My House Now or Wait?

Student Loans

Forty-three percent of Americans who attended college incurred some kind of education debt, with most outstanding loans in a recent year coming in between $20,000 and $25,000, according to the Federal Reserve.

Cumulative income gains may eclipse the cost of a student loan over time.

But higher education may be linked with greater earnings, and cumulative income gains might eclipse the cost of a student loan over time.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median weekly earnings for a bachelor’s degree holder are $1,547, which is more than $650 greater than the median weekly pay of someone with a high school diploma.

But just as taking out a mortgage is not a sure-fire way to boost net worth, student debt is not always guaranteed to result in greater earnings. The type of degree earned and area of focus, unemployment rates, and other factors will also influence an individual’s earnings.

Recommended: Staying Motivated When Paying Off Debt

What Is Considered Bad Debt?

Credit Card Debt

Credit cards can be useful financial tools if used responsibly. They may even provide cash back or other rewards. And because interest is generally not charged on purchases until the statement becomes due, using a credit card to pay for everyday purchases need not be costly if the balance on the card is paid before the billing cycle ends.

However, credit cards are often subject to high interest rates. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, the average annual interest rate for credit cards is 20.09% — but some charge rates even higher.

Credit card interest adds up, making that takeout dinner or pair of jeans far more costly than the amount shown on its price tag if a balance is carried over. For example, if you were to charge $500 in takeout food to a credit card with a 20% APR but only pay the $10 minimum each month, it would take nine years to pay off the full balance. The total amount paid — including interest — would be $1,084. That’s more than double the cost of those takeout meals!

Recommended: Does Net Worth Include Home Equity?

Car Loans

The dollar value of your car may not be what you think it is. Cars famously start to lose value the second you drive them off the lot. A new vehicle loses 20% or more of its value in the first year of ownership, according to Kelley Blue Book. After five years, a car purchased for $40,000 will be worth $16,000, a decrease in value of 60%.

But a car may also be necessary for getting around. For some individuals, owning a car can also help them earn or boost income, reducing or negating depreciation.

The Takeaway

Both good debt and bad debt can be stressful — and both types of debt can be more costly than they need to be if you don’t keep tabs on what you owe and pay back loans efficiently. A digital tracker could be the remedy.

SoFi gives you the information you need to manage debt, providing real-time financial insights and tracking so you can stay on top of what you owe.

Get spending breakdowns, credit score monitoring, and more — at no cost.

SoFi Relay offers users the ability to connect both SoFi accounts and external accounts using Plaid, Inc.’s service. When you use the service to connect an account, you authorize SoFi to obtain account information from any external accounts as set forth in SoFi’s Terms of Use. Based on your consent SoFi will also automatically provide some financial data received from the credit bureau for your visibility, without the need of you connecting additional accounts. SoFi assumes no responsibility for the timeliness, accuracy, deletion, non-delivery or failure to store any user data, loss of user data, communications, or personalization settings. You shall confirm the accuracy of Plaid data through sources independent of SoFi. The credit score is a VantageScore® based on TransUnion® (the “Processing Agent”) data.

*Terms and conditions apply. This offer is only available to new SoFi users without existing SoFi accounts. It is non-transferable. One offer per person. To receive the rewards points offer, you must successfully complete setting up Credit Score Monitoring. Rewards points may only be redeemed towards active SoFi accounts, such as your SoFi Checking or Savings account, subject to program terms that may be found here: SoFi Member Rewards Terms and Conditions. SoFi reserves the right to modify or discontinue this offer at any time without notice.

External Websites: The information and analysis provided through hyperlinks to third-party websites, while believed to be accurate, cannot be guaranteed by SoFi. Links are provided for informational purposes and should not be viewed as an endorsement.

Third-Party Brand Mentions: No brands, products, or companies mentioned are affiliated with SoFi, nor do they endorse or sponsor this article. Third-party trademarks referenced herein are property of their respective owners.

Financial Tips & Strategies: The tips provided on this website are of a general nature and do not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation, and needs. You should always consider their appropriateness given your own circumstances.

SORL0423011

Share lending is when investment firms loan shares to borrowers as a way to collect additional revenue on stocks they already hold. This produces another revenue stream on equities that would otherwise sit untraded in their portfolios.

The borrowers of the shares are often short sellers, who give collateral in the form of cash or other securities to the lenders.

What Is Share Lending?

Share lending is very much as it sounds: Institutions lend out shares of stock to other investors in order to generate more revenue.

The lenders tend to be pension funds, mutual funds, sovereign wealth funds, and exchange-traded fund (ETF) providers, since these types of firms tend to be long-term holders of equities.

Brokerages can also practice securities lending with shares in retail investors’ brokerage accounts. Share lending can help such firms keep management fees down for their clients.

Share lending is also known as securities lending, as the practice can extend beyond equities to bonds and commodities. Securities lending has become more popular in recent years as increased competition in the brokerage space drove down management fees to near-zero, and investment firms sought other sources of revenue. Worldwide revenue from securities lending totaled $9.89 billion during 2022.

Share lending is also useful to investors who are shorting stock, because those investors need to borrow shares in order to open their positions.

Critics argue that the practice comes at the expense of fund investors, since investment firms forgo their voting rights when they loan out shares. They might also try to own stocks that are easier to rent out.

Other concerns about share lending include a lack of transparency, and an increase in counterparty risk. That said, because short-sellers often use margin trading as a way to increase their potential returns, they’re likely used to assuming risk.

How Securities Lending Works

Here’s a deeper breakdown of how share lending works:

1.    Institutional investors use in-house or third-party agents to match their shares with borrowers. Such agents receive a cut of the fee generated by the loan.

2.    The fee is agreed upon in advance and typically tied to how much demand there is for the lent-out security on the market.

3.    The institutional investor or lender often reinvests the collateral in order to collect additional interest or income while their shares are out on loan.

4.    Borrowers tend to be other banks, hedge funds, or broker-dealers, and sometimes include other lending agents. When the borrower is done using the shares, they return them back to the lender.

5.    If the collateral posted was in the form of cash, a percentage of the revenue earned from reinvesting is sometimes given back to the borrower.

Retail investors should learn whether their brokerage offers securities lending or share-lending programs. If you have a margin account at a brokerage or with a specific investing platform, there’s a good chance that you may be eligible or given access to a share-lending program. But you’ll need to ask your specific brokerage for details.

For some dividend stocks, investors could get some form of payment from the borrower, rather than the dividend itself. This payment may be taxed at a higher rate than a dividend payout.

Share Lending and Short Selling

In order to short a stock, investors usually first borrow shares. They then sell these shares to another investor or trader, with the hope that when or if the stock’s price falls, the short seller can buy them back and pocket the difference, before returning the loaned shares.

In share lending, a share can only be loaned out once — but when the borrower is a short seller, they can sell it, and the new buyer can lend it again. This is why the short stock float — the percentage of the share float that is shorted — can rise above 100% in a stock.

The fee generated by lending out shares depends on their availability. A small number of stocks tend to account for a large proportion of revenue in securities lending.

Criticism of Securities Lending

The lack of transparency in securities lending is a concern for many investors — both retail, and institutional.

The Dark Side of Share Lending

In December 2019, Japan’s Government Pension Investment Fund, among the world’s largest, announced that it would halt stock lending, saying the practice is not in line with its goals as a long-term investor. They further cited a lack of transparency regarding the identity of the individuals or entities borrowing the loaned securities, as well as their motivations for borrowing.

This became a bigger concern for investors after the “cum-ex” scandal in Germany, where borrowed shares were allegedly used in a tax evasion scheme.

Voting Rights Transferred

Another one of the biggest criticisms of share lending is that shareholder voting rights attached to the actual stock are transferred to the borrower.

This practice challenges the traditional model, in which institutional investors vote and push for change in companies in order to maximize shareholder value for their investors. Money managers can recall shares in order to cast a vote in an upcoming shareholder meeting. But there are concerns that they don’t, and it’s unclear how often they do.

A Hidden Problem

Another concern is that share lending programs incentivize money managers to own stocks that are popular to borrow, but may underperform. A 2017 paper entitled “Distortions Caused By Lending Fee Retention,” updated in July 2022, found that mutual funds that practice securities lending tend to overweight high-fee stocks which then underperform versus funds that do not rent out shares.

Pros and Cons of Share Lending

There are numerous pros and cons to share lending.

Pros

The most obvious upside for investors is that they may be able to open up an additional revenue stream to increase their returns by lending their shares. Along the same lines, share lending can also help investors turn otherwise dormant investments into return-boosters, under the right circumstances.

Also, lending shares allows for investors to lend their shares to short-sellers — thereby greasing the wheels of the market and allowing short-sellers to do their work. It adds liquidity to the market, in other words.

Cons

One downside to share lending is that retail investors should take note that securities that have been loaned are not protected by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). The SIPC, however, does protect the cash collateral received for the loaned securities for up to $250,000.

There can also be negative tax consequences when lending out shares of stock. You don’t receive dividends for the stocks you’ve loaned out, but you do get Payment in Lieu that’s equal to the value of the dividends paid on loan shares. Unfortunately, though, these payments are taxed at your marginal tax rate, not the more favorable dividend rate.

Another concern is the increase in counterparty risk (similar to credit risk). Let’s say a short seller’s wager goes sour. If the shorted stock rallies enough, the short seller could default and there’s a risk that the collateral posted to the lender isn’t enough to cover the cost of the shares on loan.

Finally, there may be additional and special criteria that investors need to meet in order to qualify for share-lending programs. This will depend on individual brokerages or platforms, however. And a final note: If you use a platform that allows you to buy or trade fractional shares, those fractional shares may not be eligible for share lending, either.

The Takeaway

Share lending or securities lending is a potential source of revenue for institutional investors and brokerage firms, who rent out shares that otherwise would have sat idly in portfolios. The practice has ramped up in recent years as management and brokerage fees have shrunk dramatically due to competition and the popularity of index investing.

There are pros and cons, however, as there’s always a risk that a borrower could default. That’s offset, naturally, by the chance to earn additional revenue and boost your ultimate returns. But there are no guarantees.

If you’re interested in investing in stocks, you can start building your portfolio with SoFi Invest. When you open an Active Invest account, you can start trading stocks online with SoFi Invest’s secure, streamlined platform today. And you may qualify for share lending, which could bring in some income.

FAQ

What are the risks of share lending?

Some of the biggest risks of share lending are counterparty risk (or, the risk that a borrower will default and not be able to return your shares); the fact that you may lose SIPC protection on your shares; and that you may need to qualify in order to actually lend shares.

What exactly happens when you lend shares?

When you lend shares, ownership is temporarily transferred to a borrower, who transfers other shares or investments to the lender as collateral. The borrower also pays the lender a fee for the privilege of borrowing their shares.

Does share lending save money?

It doesn’t necessarily save money, but it can be a way to earn more money or drive more revenue from your owned investments. By lending out shares, you can garner fees from borrowers, amounting to a boost to your overall return.

For members enrolled in the Apex Fully Paid Securities Lending Program, securities are lent based on the Master Securities Lending Agreement. Members are eligible to receive a monthly payment if Apex lends out any securities. The payment is a percentage of the total net proceeds earned, which is subject to change. There are risks with share lending, for a detailed review of those risks please review the Important Disclosure. Members may opt out of the Securities Lending Program at any time by sending us a message via chat.
SoFi Invest®