Spotting Cashier’s Check Scams and Fraud
Consumers often use cashier’s checks for larger purchases because they offer the recipient of the funds extra security. That’s because cashier’s checks are guaranteed by a bank, rather than the purchaser.
Unfortunately, printing technology has improved over recent decades, making it easier for scammers to print fraudulent cashier’s checks at home and trick unsuspecting consumers into accepting them as legitimate forms of payment. Knowing how to spot a fake cashier’s check is crucial to avoiding these scams.
Learn how cashier’s checks work, common scams using them, and how to protect yourself.
Key Points
• Cashier’s checks are secure, bank-guaranteed checks used for large transactions, providing assurance to recipients.
• Scammers use advanced printing technology to create fake cashier’s checks, misleading consumers.
• Employment, overpayment, and windfall scams commonly involve counterfeit cashier’s checks.
• Verifying a cashier’s check involves directly contacting the issuing bank to confirm its legitimacy.
• Victims of counterfeit cashier’s checks should report the fraud to authorities to mitigate financial loss.
What Is a Cashier’s Check?
A cashier’s check is a check issued and guaranteed by a bank or credit union. This typically instills confidence in the recipient that the check won’t bounce when they deposit it at their own financial institution. They are common in real estate transactions and when making large purchases.
When you deposit a cashier’s check in your checking account, the money usually clears faster than a traditional personal check. Cashier’s checks can be more secure because they are more challenging to forge — though it’s not impossible.
Recommended: Certified Check vs. Cashier’s Check
How Do Cashier’s Checks Work?
Cashier’s checks are like a prepaid check. If you need to pay someone with a cashier’s check, you can go to your bank to purchase one. The money will immediately leave your account, and you can give the cashier’s check to the person or business as payment. When they deposit the cashier’s check, your bank will release the funds to cover the cost.
• If you don’t have a bank, you may still be able to get a cashier’s check from a financial institution. Rather than withdraw the funds from your account, the bank would instead require that you pay cash to have a cashier’s check issued.
• Cashier’s checks are usually not free. On top of the amount to be paid with the check, banks usually charge around $8 to $15 to issue a cashier’s check.
4 Common Cashier’s Check Scams
Just as there are many types of bank fraud in general, cashier’s check scams run the gamut, but most follow a similar structure. Typically, a fraudster will give you a fake cashier’s check that looks real, and they’ll ask you to deposit it and then send some money back to them. Afterward, the bank will discover that the original cashier’s check was fake — and you’ll owe all the money back, including the amount you sent to the scammer.
Here are the specifics on a few common scams to watch out for:
Employment Scams
Two popular employment scams include fake cashier’s checks:
• Mystery shopper scam: In this scam, the fraudster will hire people to report on the quality of various money transfer businesses as mystery shoppers. As part of the assessment, the victim of the scam will receive a cashier’s check to deposit at a local bank, then send the money back to the employer through a money transfer service (say, a wire transfer) to evaluate the service. After sending the cash back to the fake employer, the victim will learn from the bank that the cashier’s check was fraudulent. Instead, the funds sent to the scammer came out of the “real” funds in their bank account.
• Work-from-home scam: Another employment scam involves hiring remote employees and sending them an overpayment. The supposed employer might send a starting bonus via cashier’s check. The fake employer just asks that new employees pay an account activation fee to cover the cost. If successful, the scammer will receive the funds for this fee before the victim realizes the cashier’s check is fake.
In addition, some remote work scams may be overpayment scans, described below.
Windfall Scams
Windfall scams are common and often involve a cashier’s check. In a popular scheme, scammers will lead victims to believe they’ve won the lottery (usually a foreign lottery); in others, victims will learn they’ve received an inheritance.
To claim the earnings, however, the victim must pay taxes and fees. They’ll cash the fake cashier’s check they have been sent and wire money to the scammer before learning that the cashier’s check was fake. You’ll then have to repay the bank — and be out the money you paid the fraudster.
Recommended: Terrible Financial Advice to Avoid
Purchase and Overpayment Scams
The overpayment scam is a common type of cashier’s check fraud. If you sell a product to someone online, like through an online auction or marketplace (eBay, Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace), the scammer may send you a cashier’s check for more than the purchase price.
When you point this out to the scammer, they’ll apologize, say they made a mistake, and ask you to send the difference back to them. After you send them some money, you’ll discover that the original cashier’s check was fake — so you’ll have lost money as well as the product you’re selling.
In other cases, the buyer may give you a cashier’s check for the right amount. You’ll ship them the product, only to later discover the check was fake. While you aren’t out any money, you’re still out the product.
Overpayment scams may also take the form of remote work scenarios. You will be sent a check and then be asked to forward a portion of it to another party as part of your “new job.” Alas, if you do so, you could discover the check was a fake and the money you forwarded is now lost.
Property Rental Scams
If you are a landlord renting out a property, be wary of cashier’s checks. In some cases, scammers may offer to pay the first and last months’ rent payment plus the security deposit without ever seeing the property — often because they claim they are moving for a new job and need a place fast.
They’ll send you the money via cashier’s check, then back out of the rental, saying the job fell through. The scammer will offer to let you keep the security deposit but ask if you’d be willing to wire any of the prepaid rent back. Only after sending the money will you realize the scammer paid you with a fake cashier’s check.
Tips for Spotting Fake Cashier’s Checks
Wondering how to spot a fake cashier’s check? Here are a few tips:
• Check the bank name: Some scammers utilize real banks’ names and information, which makes it harder to differentiate between a real and fake cashier’s check. But a dead giveaway is a cashier’s check with a fake bank name. A quick online search can help you identify a bogus name.
• Check the postmark: If you received the check in the mail, the postmark city should match the city of the supposed bank.
• Verify the amount: A cashier’s check for the incorrect amount could be the sign of a scam in the works, such as an overpayment ruse.
• Look for security features: Real cashier’s checks use a combination of security features, like color-changing ink, security threads, and watermarks. While fake cashier’s checks might contain these as well, a check without these hallmarks is an obvious indication of a scam.
• Check the payee name: If the payee’s name line is blank, you are probably in possession of a fake cashier’s check.
Recommended: How to Build Financial Security
Tips for Avoiding Cashier’s Check Scams
Knowing how to spot a fake cashier’s check can be helpful, but here are some tips for avoiding scenarios where you’d receive a fraudulent cashier’s check altogether:
• Only accept cashier’s checks from people you know and trust.
• Consider a traceable online payment system for doing business, instead of a cashier’s check.
• Accept cashier’s checks only for the agreed-upon amount, never more.
• Use your judgment: If someone is sending you money you weren’t expecting, especially if they’re a stranger, it’s likely too good to be true.
• Don’t agree to send anyone money until you’ve verified with your bank that the cashier’s check has cleared and was free of fraud.
Verifying Cashier’s Checks
If you are accepting this kind of check, it’s important to learn to spot a real vs. fake cashier’s check and keep your eyes peeled for signs of fraud. A good way to avoid a cashier’s check scam can be to verify the check with the issuing bank. You can call or visit the bank in person, if there’s a branch nearby.
Just don’t use the phone number that might be printed on the questionable check, as it may go to the scammer. Instead, search for the bank online, find its legitimate website, and call the customer service number. Provide the check number, issue date, and amount — and the bank should be able to verify if the check is legitimate.
Do Victims of Cashier’s Check Fraud Have Any Recourse?
If you have already sent money to a scammer in an untraceable way, like via wire transfer, you may not be able to get your money back. Banks can deduct the amount of the fraudulent check from your account or require you to pay for the amount you withdrew using the fraudulent check. Some points to note:
• You can report the fraud to the United States Postal Inspection Service (if the check came in the mail), your state or local consumer protection agencies, and the Internet Crime Complaint Center.
• You can contact the bank whose name appeared on the fake cashier’s check, as well as the bank where you deposited the fake cashier’s check. Additionally, you’ll want to notify the platform on which you first encountered the scammer (for example, an apartment rental site or an online marketplace).
• Submit a formal complaint to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and file a police report with the local police.
These steps may help you resolve the case and/or prevent the scammers from perpetuating more fraud.
Recommended: What Is an E-Check?
The Takeaway
Cashier’s checks are a legitimate form of payment often used in high-dollar transactions or to add a sense of confidence between buyers and sellers who don’t know each other. However, they can be easy for scammers to forge, so it’s important to stay alert when receiving a cashier’s check as payment. Knowing the difference between a real vs. fake cashier’s check can be an important skill in protecting your finances.
FAQ
How can I verify if a cashier’s check is real?
You can inspect a cashier’s check for obvious signs that it’s a fake, like a missing payee name, a fake bank name, and incorrect amounts. But if you’re dealing with a more sophisticated fake cashier’s check, your best bet is to find the bank online, call their customer service number, and ask them to confirm the check’s authenticity.
What happens if you deposit a fake cashier’s check?
Once the bank discovers that the cashier’s check you deposited was fake, they’ll deduct that amount from your account or seek repayment some other way. In instances where you’ve sent some money back to the scammer, you’ll be out that money. In instances where you sold goods to a scammer, you’ll unfortunately be unlikely to get the item back.
Can a bank tell if a cashier’s check is real?
Bank tellers may also have difficulty determining if a cashier’s check is fake or real. While they can spot the more obvious signs, more sophisticated scammers can slip fake cashier’s checks past bank tellers. Internally, banks eventually discover that the cashier’s check is fake (usually a couple of weeks later when it’s returned unpaid), long after the fraudster has gotten away with their scam.
Photo credit: iStock/Richard Stephen
Financial Tips & Strategies: The tips provided on this website are of a general nature and do not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation, and needs. You should always consider their appropriateness given your own circumstances.
Third-Party Brand Mentions: No brands, products, or companies mentioned are affiliated with SoFi, nor do they endorse or sponsor this article. Third-party trademarks referenced herein are property of their respective owners.
This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice.
SOBK0423026
Read more