SoFi

The federal Direct Consolidation Loan program can help you manage your federal student loans. However, it also means a new loan account turns up on your credit report. You may be concerned about whether consolidating student loans in this way has a positive or negative impact on your credit. The short answer is that it can indirectly do both, but to varying degrees.

To help you understand exactly how your credit could change, read on. You’ll learn the ins and outs, so you can decide whether consolidating your student loans is the right financial move to make.

Can Student Loan Consolidation Have a Positive Impact on Your Credit Score?

If you are considering ways to better wrangle your debt, you may wonder, “Does consolidating student loans help my credit?”

Good question. Your borrowing activity and repayment habits do impact your credit score. One of the biggest — yet indirect — effects that consolidation has on your credit score is making your payments simpler. Consider these points:

•   Thirty-five percent of your FICO® score is based on your payment history. Making consistent and full monthly payments has the most dramatic impact on your credit score on a day-to-day basis.

•   However, your student debt is likely spread across multiple loans taken out during your years of education. Each of these loans has its own payment amount and due date, making it difficult to manage.

•   A Direct Consolidation Loan can cut through the clutter. It streamlines your repayment experience, which may mean you are less likely to miss a due date or forget a payment altogether. It can set you up for a positive payment history, which is an indirect way that you can see a credit score increase after student loan consolidation.

•   Incidentally, unlike private refinance loans, it will not involve a hard credit inquiry, which usually lowers your credit score a bit for a short period of time.

💡 Quick Tip: Get flexible terms and competitive rates when you refinance your student loan with SoFi.

Can Student Loan Consolidation Hurt Your Credit Score?

Consolidating student loans can affect your credit score in a negative way, too. Can consolidating student loan debt hurt your credit score? To some extent, it might.

Here’s a closer look:

•   Fifteen percent of your FICO credit score calculation looks at the length of your credit history. It considers the age of your oldest credit account, like the first student loan you borrowed during your freshman year of school, and the age of your newest account. It also determines the average age of all of your open accounts.

•   Having open accounts that you’re actively repaying helps you build credit over time. Consolidating your original student loans effectively closes those older accounts.

•   This altered length of credit history could result in a less favorable treatment for your score. The impact on your score, however, is lessened over time as you make timely payments toward your consolidated loan.

Federal vs Private Student Loan Consolidation and Credit Score

Federal Direct Consolidation is exclusively a repayment option offered by the US Department of Education. This process doesn’t require a credit check, as noted above, and most federal loans can be consolidated.

In terms of private student loans, they are ineligible for Direct Loan consolidation. However, you can refinance existing federal student loans or private loans with a private lender. Understand these points:

•   If you decide to refinance student loans with a private lender, the process is similar to Direct Loan Consolidation in that it combines existing education loans into one. You can do this both as undergraduate and graduate school loan refinancing.

•   The newly refinanced loan is considered private student debt. It may be for a lower rate than you previously had, or it could offer a lower monthly payment for a longer term. (Note that when you refinance with an extended term, you may pay more interest over the life of the loan.)

•   The refinance lender pays off the student loans you’ve chosen to include and creates a new refinance loan. You’ll repay the refinance lender for the total balance of the combined loan, but at a new rate and repayment terms.

•   It’s important to recognize that when you refinance federal loans as private loans, they will no longer qualify for federal benefits and protection programs, such as deferment and forbearance. For these reasons, it’s wise to carefully consider whether refinancing federal loans is the right option for you.

Alternatives to Student Loan Consolidation

If, after weighing the pros and cons of student loan consolidation, you find it’s not for you, there are other repayment options available.

Income-Driven Repayment

One advantage of a Direct Consolidation Loan is it lets you make smaller monthly installments over a longer term. If, however, you can’t make your monthly federal loan payments for the foreseeable future, ask your servicer about income-driven repayment (IDR).

IDR offers repayment terms of 20 or 25 years, depending on the plan you’re on. Your income, family size, and chosen IDR plan determine what your reduced monthly payment is. For some eligible borrowers, your monthly payment could be as low as $0.

Additionally, if you still have a remaining balance after completing your IDR plan, the balance might qualify for loan forgiveness.

Federal Deferment or Forbearance

If you’re experiencing short-term financial hardship, you might be able to delay your federal student loan payments temporarily. The Department of Education offers deferment and forbearance programs that let you pause your payments without the loan going into default.

Keep in mind that while loans are in deferment, interest might accrue on certain federal loans. If you’ve requested forbearance, interest is charged during this period, regardless of the federal loan you have.

Student Loan Refinancing

Private student loans, mentioned above, aren’t eligible for the two alternatives just described. However, they may be a good solution in some situations. For instance, they might be a helpful option if you have private student loans that you are struggling to pay or have federal student loans and don’t have plans to take advantage of federal benefits (remember, you’ll forfeit those plus other protections).

Since private student loan refinancing requires a credit check, it’s best for borrowers with good credit. A student loan refinance might help you secure a lower interest rate or a lower monthly payment at a different repayment term. Private lenders have their own eligibility requirements, rates, and refinancing offers.

Shop around and try a student loan refinancing calculator to compare your offers and see if refinancing makes sense for you.

The Takeaway

Consolidating your federal loans has little direct effect on your score over the long term. Its effect on your age of credit accounts might temporarily lower your score. However, if consolidating means securing a lower, more manageable payment or unlocking federal benefits, the impact on your credit might be worth it.

However, if your main concern is getting relief from high monthly student loan payments, speak to your loan servicer or lender ASAP to see if your loans qualify for other repayment options. In some cases, refinancing with a private lender may be a good decision.

Looking to lower your monthly student loan payment? Refinancing may be one way to do it — by extending your loan term, getting a lower interest rate than what you currently have, or both. (Please note that refinancing federal loans makes them ineligible for federal forgiveness and protections. Also, lengthening your loan term may mean paying more in interest over the life of the loan.) SoFi student loan refinancing offers flexible terms that fit your budget.

FAQ

Can consolidating student loans directly raise your credit score?

No, consolidating your student loans doesn’t directly raise your credit score. It can simplify your monthly payments and possibly reduce your payment amount (though possibly extending your term and charging more interest over the life of the loan). These factors can help you maintain on-time payments, which can help build your score.

Can consolidating student loans directly lower your credit score?

Does student loan consolidation hurt your credit? It might temporarily lower your score: Loan consolidation can add a new open account to your credit record while closing an older one, which negatively affects your average length of credit history. Also, a new private loan can involve a hard credit inquiry, which can temporarily reduce your number.

Are there any indirect effects of student loan refinancing on your credit score?

Yes. Private student loan refinancing requires a hard credit check. This credit inquiry can temporarily lower your score by a few points for a short period of time. Additionally, refinancing might affect your average age of credit accounts and other factors that contribute to your credit score.

Photo credit: iStock/Ridofranz

SoFi Student Loan Refinance
SoFi Student Loans are originated by SoFi Bank, N.A. Member FDIC. NMLS #696891. (www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org). SoFi Student Loan Refinance Loans are private loans and do not have the same repayment options that the federal loan program offers, or may become available, such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness, Income-Based Repayment, Income-Contingent Repayment, PAYE or SAVE. Additional terms and conditions apply. Lowest rates reserved for the most creditworthy borrowers. For additional product-specific legal and licensing information, see SoFi.com/legal.

SOSL0322021

A central counterparty clearing house (CCP), or Central Counterparty, is a financial institution that facilitates trading activities in European equity and derivative markets. Regional banks typically operate CCPs which are an important part of the international financial system.

CCPs maintain stability and efficiency across financial markets and reduce risks including counterparty, default, and market risks. In the United States, CCPs are called Derivatives Clearing Organizations (DCO) and are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

Defining Central Counterparty Clearing Houses

The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) defines a CCP as “a clearing house that interposes itself between counterparties to contracts traded in one or more financial markets, becoming the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer and thereby ensuring the future performance of open contracts.” The Eurex is a well known CCP.

Central Counterparty Clearing Houses act as intermediaries between buyers and sellers in financial transactions. They handle clearing and settlements in various types of securities and derivatives transactions to reduce credit risk in the markets. Clearinghouses have existed for more than a century, and act as a way to reduce the risk of OTC derivative transactions.

💡 Quick Tip: How do you decide if a certain trading platform or app is right for you? Ideally, the investment platform you choose offers the features that you need for your investment goals or strategy, e.g., an easy-to-use interface, data analysis, educational tools.

How Central Counterparty Clearing Houses Work

Central Counterparty Clearing Houses guarantee trade terms for buyers and sellers. They help reduce risk for investors by taking on credit risk involved in transactions, so even if a buyer or seller defaults on a transaction the other party doesn’t have as much loss as they might have without the CCP.

When buyers and sellers enter into transactions, they each deposit money with the CCP to cover the amount of the transaction. All CCP users must have a margin account.

In a process called “novation,” the CCP enters into two different contracts, one with the buyer and one with the seller. This provides a guarantee to the other party that if one side doesn’t follow through with the agreement the other side will still receive payment. CCPs typically use margin calls to settle trades if one party does not have the funds in their account.

If the trade falls through, the CCP completes the trade at the current market price. CCPs are for-profit businesses that generate revenue from their members and their transactions. They also work with parent exchanges that require them to remain profitable. Just like other types of businesses, CCPs each operate differently and have different business strategies to attract customers and earn revenue.

For instance, there are different types of derivative products that a CCP might choose to offer. One common business model for CCPs is to cross-margin products in a single netting pool. Parent exchanges place obligations on CCPs, so they need to earn enough revenue to meet those.

The specific financial products offered by a CCP, as well as its risk level, fee structure, and other features lead to different types of members, organizational structure, regulations, and rules for margin balances.

CCPs continue to evolve, offer new products, and become more sophisticated over time. Regulations are also evolving for CCPs which may change how they operate in the future.

Uses of a Central Counterparty Clearing House

CCPs maintain the anonymity of investors’ identities to protect their privacy. They also maintain the privacy of trading firms from buyers and sellers by using electronic order books and protect brokerage firms from the risk of buyers and sellers defaulting on their end of options such as calls or puts.

Another use of CCPs is to lower the number of transactions settled in order to move funds efficiently between investors.

💡 Quick Tip: How to manage potential risk factors in a self-directed investment account? Doing your research and employing strategies like dollar-cost averaging and diversification may help mitigate financial risk when trading stocks.

CCP Members

Financial institutions that want to clear trades through a central counterparty can become members of a particular CCP. Membership allows them to reduce credit risk for their customers and themselves. There are CCPs for different types of financial transactions, so financial institutions can choose the appropriate CCP to apply to for their needs.

CCPs want members that have a significant transaction volume, are creditworthy, and have a trading operation that works efficiently with the system run by the CCP. CCPs also want members to contribute funds to their default fund and secure collateral for their transactions. Each CCP has somewhat different criteria and requirements for membership, and membership information is not always publicly available.

Pros and Cons of CCPs

There are benefits and drawbacks to CCPs. Here are a few important ones to understand:

Pros

CCPs benefit investors in the following ways:

•   Reduce counterparty risk

•   Maintain stability in financial markets

•   Increase efficiency of transactions

•   Maintains privacy of customers

Cons

There are also some drawbacks to CCPs for investors, including the following:

•   Participation fees

•   May not be able to process non-standard transactions

•   Some CCPs may not have adequate scale

CCPs and Blockchain

CCPs are now being used with blockchain technology, made popular in cryptocurrency markets, to further reduce risk and costs. An international group of clearing houses launched the Post Trade Distributed Ledger Group launched in 2015. The group studies ways to use blockchain technology for transactions.

Since its formation, the group has expanded to include about 40 global financial institutions collaborating to bring CCPs together with blockchain. The goal of using blockchain technology with CCPs is to reduce margin requirements and risk, reduce operational costs, improve regulatory oversight, and increase the efficiency of trade settlements. Ideally blockchain can help support better settlements, clearing processes, and reporting.

Decentralized exchanges already operate similarly to CCPs as a third party that handles transactions.

The Takeaway

Central counterparty clearing houses help reduce the risk of trading derivatives and securities. They became more popular after the financial crisis as a way for investors to minimize counterparty risk.

While CCPs may help maintain stability in financial markets and increase efficiency, they may also involve participation fees, or may not be able to process non-standard transactions. Understanding the ins and outs of CCPs can be helpful to investors as they learn to navigate the markets.

Ready to invest in your goals? It’s easy to get started when you open an investment account with SoFi Invest. You can invest in stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), mutual funds, alternative funds, and more. SoFi doesn’t charge commissions, but other fees apply (full fee disclosure here).

FAQ

What is the difference between a clearing house and a central counterparty?

While a CCP acts as a clearing house for transactions, it has an additional step involved before doing so. The two parties involved in a transaction agree upon transaction terms, then the CCP must agree to the terms before they clear the transaction.

What is the CCP margin?

CCPs require customers to make collateral deposits, known as margin deposits, before entering into transactions. This provides them with funds they can use to guarantee trades in the event that one party defaults on an agreement. The initial margin required depends on the customer, the type of financial product, and the particular trade agreement.

Does central clearing reduce counterparty risk?

Central clearing reduces counterparty risk by guaranteeing trades for buyers and sellers. They take on the credit risk involved in transactions by becoming the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer.

Photo credit: iStock/vm

SoFi Invest®