SoFi

If you’re in a bind to make a credit card payment, you may wonder if you can use another card to make your minimum payment. Typically, that’s not possible, or at least you can’t make the payment directly.

There may be workarounds that allow you to pull it off indirectly, such as cash advances and balance transfers.

Here, learn the details on these options, as well as some alternatives to help out when you are short on cash and have a credit card payment due.

Avoiding the Issue in the First Place

The best way to avoid a situation in which you are considering using one credit card to pay another is by paying your entire credit card statement balance every month.

Making credit card payments in full and on time will allow you to avoid paying interest.

Paying the statement balance in full each billing cycle also reduces the chance of accumulating debt that is hard to pay off.

At the very least it is important to make minimum payments to avoid negative effects on your credit score.

Of course, many people face situations in which it becomes hard to pay bills on time. Finding a budget system that works for you is one way to manage; there are many different budgeting methods out there, and it’s like one or more will suit you.

You might also consider doing some of your spending with a debit card or cash to avoid carrying so much credit card debt.


💡 Quick Tip: Before choosing a personal loan, ask about the lender’s fees: origination, prepayment, late fees, etc. One question can save you many dollars.

Paying a Credit Card With Another Credit Card

Curious to know, “Can I use a credit card to pay off another credit card?” Most credit card rules don’t allow you to directly pay one card with another. It’s considered too expensive to process these kinds of transactions. But that said, there may be some workarounds that could allow you to use one card to pay another.

Taking a Cash Advance

You can’t pay one credit card with another directly, but you might be able to pay a credit card with a cash advance from another credit card.

Let’s say you have two credit cards: Card A and Card B. You can’t afford to make your minimum payment on Card A, so you’re looking to Card B for a little help. You have the option to take a cash advance from Card B.

You could use Card B to withdraw cash at an ATM. Then you’d deposit that money into your checking account and make an online payment from your bank account or with a debit card.

Pros of a Cash Advance

The pros of using a cash advance to pay another credit card aren’t numerous. Basically, you are just accessing cash when it’s urgently needed.

•   Taking out a cash advance may be the right option if your situation meets three criteria: You’re trying to pay a small amount on Card A, you already have a second credit card (Card B) to use for this transaction, and Card B has a lower interest rate than Card A.

•   Most credit card companies limit how much cash you can withdraw with your credit card per month. If your withdrawal limit from Card B is $5,000, though, and you want to make a payment of $500 on Card A, things shouldn’t get too sticky.

In this way, you can make a payment, whether the minimum or more, to the credit card that is due. By using this process, the answer to “Can I pay a credit card with a credit card?” can be yes.

Cons of a Cash Advance

While a cash advance may get the money you need into your hands, consider the cons:

•   Your credit card company might not allow you to withdraw enough money per month to pay off your other credit card. Your cash advance limit isn’t necessarily the same as your monthly spending limit. Before you take a cash advance, you may want to contact the company that issued your second card to inquire. Or check a statement.

•   Also, interest usually starts accruing on the amount you withdraw from the moment you take the cash advance. The annual percentage rate (APR) for a cash advance will typically be higher than the purchasing APR on the card. As a result, it’s possible to go even further into debt.

•   What’s more, you’ll likely pay a fee to take a cash advance. The amount will depend on the credit card company, but you can usually expect to pay the greater of $10 or 5% of the amount you withdraw.

Completing a Balance Transfer

If you don’t have another credit card, or your cash advance allowance is too low, you might consider a balance transfer, which would allow you to transfer the balance on Card A to Card B.

Ideally, Card B would have a lower interest rate or none at all. You could potentially pay off the total balance more quickly because more of the money you used to pay in interest is going to pay off the principal, or you’re not accruing interest at all.

You may complete a balance transfer only by using a designated balance transfer credit card.

Pros of a Balance Transfer

The benefit of a balance transfer is getting a reprieve on paying the high interest rates that credit cards can charge.

•   Certain credit card companies offer balance transfer credit cards with no interest for the first six months or more. When you shop around for a new card, you’ll typically hear the grace period referred to as an “introductory balance transfer APR period” or “promotional period.”

•   During this period, you can work on paying off your debt without paying any interest. This can help you manage your finances and debt better.

Cons of a Balance Transfer

While balance transfers may be a godsend for paying off your balance in a set amount of time, what if you can’t nibble away at the total balance quickly? Keep these drawbacks in mind:

•   Once the introductory balance transfer APR period ends, the interest rate will shoot up, and the balance transfer card may not seem so magical anymore.

•   If you miss a payment, most companies will suspend the introductory APR period on your new card, or Card B, and you’ll have to pay what’s known as a default rate, which could end up being even higher than the rate on your previous Card A. Even if you consider yourself responsible enough to make all your payments on time, a financial emergency could throw you off track.

•   There are also generally fees associated with balance transfers, though they’re often lower than cash advance fees.

•   It’s worth mentioning that you usually can’t use balance transfers or cash advances to get credit card points or miles.

💡 Quick Tip: Swap high-interest debt for a lower-interest loan, and save money on your monthly payments. Find out why SoFi credit card consolidation loans are so popular.

What If I Can’t Pay My Minimum?

Now you have some answers to why you can’t pay a credit card with a credit card directly. And you know the ways to get around that situation and still use plastic.

If, for whatever reason, a cash advance or balance transfer isn’t available to you, you may still have trouble making your minimum payments. If this is the case, stay calm, and assess your situation. Here are some options for a credit card debt elimination plan.

•   You may want to gather your credit card statements and put your debts in order, either from largest to smallest or from highest interest rate to lowest. This step can help you understand how much debt you’re in and how to prioritize your bills.

•   You may decide to tackle the largest debts first or even your smallest to gain momentum. Or you may decide to save money on interest by focusing on credit cards with the highest interest rate first. You may see these tactics referred to by such names as the debt avalanche or snowball repayment methods.

•   You may consider talking to your creditors to see if they can help. A credit hardship program could give you more time to pay off your balance or adjust your terms.

What About a Personal Loan?

Taking out a personal loan is an option for paying off a large credit card bill. A personal loan may come with a lower interest rate than a credit card, and may be more manageable in the long run.

Pros of a Personal Loan

Here are some of the pluses of using a personal loan to pay off credit card debt:

•   If you have a good credit score, your rate for a personal loan could potentially be lower than your credit card rate. If that is the case, you could take out a kind of personal loan called a credit card consolidation loan, and then make payments on the loan at the lower interest rate. You’d likely end up paying less in interest over time and might be able to pay back the loan more quickly than you’d be able to pay off the credit card.

•   Most credit cards come with variable interest rates, meaning the rate can change over time with shifts in the economy. An unsecured personal loan usually has a fixed rate. (Unsecured means the loan isn’t secured by collateral, like your home or car.) This can help you budget better, since you know what you owe every month.

•   Taking out a personal loan also could help your credit utilization ratio, the amount of available revolving credit you’re using. Credit utilization affects your credit score. You can build your credit score by lowering your credit utilization ratio. Your score can also be favorably affected when you consistently pay bills on time.

Cons of a Personal Loan

Taking out a personal loan to pay off a credit card isn’t for everyone. Here are some downsides to think over.

•   It might not help you take control of your finances. Maybe you have trouble controlling your spending, and that’s why you have credit card debt to begin with. Having a personal loan to fall back on could tempt you to spend even more with your credit card.

•   Also, a lower interest rate isn’t guaranteed. If you discover that your loan rate could be higher than your card’s rate after inquiring with a lender, taking out a loan may not be the best choice.

•   No matter how low your personal loan interest rate is, it will still be higher than the rate during an introductory APR period for a balance transfer.

The Takeaway

Can you pay a credit card with a credit card? Indirectly, yes, with a balance transfer or cash advance. While those moves can work in a pinch, each has potential drawbacks.

Taking out a fixed-rate personal loan with a clearly defined payment schedule may be the better long-term option.

Think twice before turning to high-interest credit cards. Consider a SoFi personal loan instead. SoFi offers competitive fixed rates and same-day funding. Checking your rate takes just a minute.

SoFi Loan Products
SoFi loans are originated by SoFi Bank, N.A., NMLS #696891 (Member FDIC). For additional product-specific legal and licensing information, see SoFi.com/legal. Equal Housing Lender.

Disclaimer: Many factors affect your credit scores and the interest rates you may receive. SoFi is not a Credit Repair Organization as defined under federal or state law, including the Credit Repair Organizations Act. SoFi does not provide “credit repair” services or advice or assistance regarding “rebuilding” or “improving” your credit record, credit history, or credit rating. For details, see the FTC’s website .

Financial Tips & Strategies: The tips provided on this website are of a general nature and do not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation, and needs. You should always consider their appropriateness given your own circumstances.

SOPL1023024

Margin variation is money needed to maintain margin level in a margin account. Variation margins serve as collateral or security against potential losses. Another way to think of it is as unrealized profit or loss in open derivative positions.

When a margin account balance drops below the brokerage’s specified limits, the brokerage can extend a margin call to request a futures variation margin payment. If a trader does not have the funds to meet the margin call, the brokerage may sell securities in their account to make up the difference.

What Is Variation Margin?

Variation margin is a collateral payment made by one party to a counterparty to cover any change in value of underlying assets used in futures contracts.

Traders may make these payments on a day-to-day or intraday basis as directed by the clearing house. Variation margin serves as a risk management tool for the clearing house. By collecting these payments, the clearing house can sustain its targeted risk level while allowing traders to have margin debt in their accounts.


💡 Quick Tip: Are self-directed brokerage accounts cost efficient? They can be, because they offer the convenience of being able to buy stocks online without using a traditional full-service broker (and the typical broker fees).

Margin Trading Basics

To understand variation margins, it’s helpful to review some of the basics of margin trading. When an investor trades on margin, it essentially means they’re trading using borrowed money. So, for example, an investor who wants to purchase futures contracts may invest 50% of their own money and borrow the remaining 50% from their brokerage.

In exchange, the brokerage requires investors to maintain an initial margin, maintenance margin, and variation margin amount in liquid funds. Each one represents a different balance threshold. Margin accounts require investors to meet the minimum requirements.

Recommended: How Does a Margin Account Work?

How Do Variation Margins Work?

Variation margin works by filling gaps in margin account balance levels. When trading futures, variation margin allows clearing houses to continue facilitating trades while managing risk. Understanding stock volatility can help with understanding how variation margin works.

Equity prices fluctuate as volatility ebbs and flows in the markets. Changing prices can directly affect investor profits or losses, and trading equity derivatives on margin can amplify those profits and losses.

Variation margins work by accounting for changes in the prices of financial securities being traded. Traders make these payments, typically in cash, from the party who lost value to the party that’s gained value in a margin transaction. The amount due depends on the type of security being traded, expected price movements for that security and overall market conditions. That’s why it’s called variation margin, as the amount may vary from transaction to transaction.

Variation Margin Example

Here’s a simple example of how variation margin works. Assume an investor purchases 100 shares of stock for $30 each. The initial margin for the purchase is set at 50%. This would mean the broker would need to have $1,500 in their account at all times in order to make trades (50% of 100 x $30). Meanwhile, the maintenance margin is $1,000.

If the stock’s share price were to fall to $20, then the brokerages would deduct $1,000 in losses from the initial margin balance. Now the initial margin balance is $500. The new initial margin amount required becomes $1,000 (50% of 100 shares x $20 per share). So the investor would have to add $500 to their account as a variation margin payment to meet the new initial margin requirement.

Variation Margin Calculation

Calculating variation margin depends on the type of security being traded and its price movements. So it’s something that must be done on a transaction-by-transaction basis, since every security is different.

But there is a simple variation margin formula that can be used for calculations:

VM = Initial margin – Margin balance

So to calculate variation margin, an investor needs to know three things:

•   Initial margin requirement

•   Maintenance margin requirement

•   Current price of the underlying security

Finding variation margin means doing some math to determine how much the new initial margin requirement works out to when the price of the underlying security drops. But as the previous variation example illustrates, it’s not overly complicated.

Initial Margin vs Variation Margin

Initial margin and variation margin are often mentioned together when discussing margin trading but they’re not the same thing. Initial margin refers to the amount of money an investor can borrow inside a margin account.

Regulation T of the Federal Reserve Board allows investors to borrow up to 50% of the purchase price of securities being traded on margin. Though some brokerages may require a larger deposit to satisfy initial margin requirements.

Variation Margin and Maintenance Margin

Maintenance margin is another term often used in discussions of margin trading and it’s often used synonymously with variation margin. The maintenance margin represents the minimum amount of equity a trader must maintain in a margin account at all times. Equity is the difference between the value of securities held in the account and any amounts owed to the brokerage.

Under Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) rules, maintenance margin must be at least 25% of the total market value of margin securities being held. Brokerage firms set the bar higher, however, requiring investors to meet a 30% or 40% margin maintenance requirement.

The maintenance margin is not the same thing as minimum margin. Minimum margin is the minimum amount required to open a margin account. FINRA requires this amount to be $2,000 or 100% of the purchase price of margin securities, whichever is less.


💡 Quick Tip: Investment fees are assessed in different ways, including trading costs, account management fees, and possibly broker commissions. When you set up an investment account, be sure to get the exact breakdown of your “all-in costs” so you know what you’re paying.

The Takeaway

To recap, variation margin is a collateral payment made by one party to a counterparty to cover any change in value of underlying assets when discussing futures contracts. It’s a fairly high-level concept, and many investors may not need to worry much about it, or even encounter it if they stick to a relatively simple investment strategy.

With that said, margin trading can potentially yield significant returns for investors, though it has more risks than traditional trading. Understanding variation margin and margin requirements can help traders manage that risk.

Ready to invest in your goals? It’s easy to get started when you open an investment account with SoFi Invest. You can invest in stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), mutual funds, alternative funds, and more. SoFi doesn’t charge commissions, but other fees apply (full fee disclosure here).

FAQ

Is variation margin a derivative?

Variation margin is not a derivative, but is a factor in derivatives markets. It’s one of the chief types of collateral that is required to protect investors or other parties in the market.

Is variation margin the same as mark to market?

Variation margin is a type of collateral, and is determined, in part, but the size of a party’s exposure in a trade – that, too, depends on mark-to-market value of the derivatives at play. As such, the two are not the same.

Can variation margin be negative?

It is possible for variation margin to be negative, and in that case, it would mean that there’s been a loss.

Is variation margin collateral?

Variation margin is a type of collateral, and is payment made by one party to a counterparty to cover any change in value of underlying assets used in futures contracts.

Why is variation margin important?

For investors or traders, variation margin is important as it informs them of the amount of funds that they need to solidify margin levels in order to trade.

Photo credit: iStock/Prostock-Studio

SoFi Invest®